“Before the fall” by Noah Hawley – Book Review

before the fallA private plane crashes sixteen minutes after taking off from Martha’s Vineyard.  Aboard are eleven people.  The Bateman family of four (David, Maggie, nine-year old Rachel and four-year old JJ) and their security guard Gil Baruch, Ben and Sarah Kipling, a couple who are friends of the family, Scott Burroughs, an artist who is aboard only by chance, and a flight crew of three.

Was the crash a tragic accident, or something more sinister?

Only the artist and the four-year old son of the plane’s owners survive.  And this only due to the quick thinking and expert swimming skills of the artist, Scott Burroughs.  He swam over eight miles in rough seas with a dislocated shoulder and a small boy on his back.  A hero, some would say…1

The novel quickly delves into events that took place “Before the Fall” – or crash.  Chapters are devoted to individual members of the planes’ passengers in the time immediately leading up to the crash in an attempt for the reader to discern the cause of the tragedy.

An official investigation into the crash is being led by NTSB investigator Gus Franklin and the FBI.  The SEC is also involved due to the fact that Ben Kipling had been due to be indicted the day following the crash.Wall ST

Every novel needs a ‘bad guy’ and in this one it was Bill Cunningham.  He worked for David Bateman, a media mogul,  and was the on-air face of the television news at his station.  A suspender-wearing news anchor who just happens to be the godfather of the surviving boy, JJ Bateman.

“Tragedy is drama you can’t bear to relive”.

Beautifully written, this novel explores the vagaries of fate and of memory. It also expounds on how wealth corrupts – both the attainment of wealth and the sudden acquisition of it.  It discusses journalistic integrity and how modern technology and the media can be both a help and a hindrance when dealing with the more human side of tragic events.  It philosophizes upon the certainty of death, the arrogance of money, and the subjectivity of truth.

Although I enjoyed the flow of the language and writing, in my humble opinion there were too many characters.  A reader has to identify with a protagonist and since most characters were given equal space, there didn’t seem to be one.  I found myself wanted to skim through the extraneous detail of some of the characters – something I seldom if ever do.

Scott Burroughs was my favorite, and I found myself reading just to see what part he played in events, if any.  A recovering alcoholic, Scott has reinvented his career and has formed a strong bond with the little boy he saved.

I was also interested in JJ’s aunt who has been tasked as his caregiver and trustee of his multi-million dollar inheritance.

Though I can understand its appeal, this book took me longer than usual to read.  I just wasn’t invested in it enough I guess.

If you hear hoofbeats, think horses NOT zebras.  In other words, look for the simplest, most common answer first.   I was thinking of this saying the entire time I read this novel.

Thanks to Hachette/Grand Central Publishing via NetGalley for providing me with a digital copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review.

F 3.5 star

written with planes

Noah Hawley (photo credit Leah Muse)

Noah Hawley
(photo credit Leah Muse)

Noah Hawley is an American film and television producer, screenwriter, composer, and author. He wrote and produced the television series Bones (2005-present) and also created The Unusuals (2009) and My Generation (2010). Hawley also wrote the screenplay for the film Lies and Alibis (2006) starring Steve Coogan and Rebecca Romijn.

Noah is the author of five novels including A Conspiracy of Tall Men, Other People’s Weddings , The Punch, and The Good Father.

“Before the fall” is Noah Hawley’s fifth novel.


About Fictionophile

Fiction reviewer ; Goodreads librarian. Retired library cataloger - more time to read! Loves books, gardening, and red wine. I have been a reviewer member of NetGalley since October 2013. I review titles offered by Edelweiss, and participate in blog tours with TLC Book Tours.
This entry was posted in Book Reviews, NetGalley, Suspense and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to “Before the fall” by Noah Hawley – Book Review

  1. skyecaitlin says:

    Thanks for you candor, Lynne: I was getting uncomfortable about the tragic crash, but then hooked in by a certain phrase you wrote: ” Beautifully written, this novel….” but then the idea of tragedy and too many characters basically free me from the need to put this on my TBR list.
    At first, it reminded of Kavanaugh’s novel, Fallen.


  2. Annie says:

    I got rejected and I removed it from my TBR list hahaha…


  3. annelogan17 says:

    I’ve got this book on my shelf right now-only problem is, I’m such an anxious flier, so I’m worried this book is going to make my phobia worse!


    • Fictionophile says:

      At the risk of providing you with a ‘spoiler’, I don’t think this will make your phobia any worse. LOL


  4. Christine says:

    Well thought out review, Lynne. I remain on the fence with this one.


  5. Everyone reads this novel, but no one seems to like it. You were the only reviewer who didn’t mention all the suspicion placed on the artist, which I find interesting!


    • Fictionophile says:

      Thanks for the comment. The parts of the novel featuring the artist Scott Burroughs were my favorite. In my opinion the author should have delved more deeply into his character and less into the other characters. The suspicion of the artist, in my view, was absolutely foolish. Who would crash a plane on purpose so that he could swim eight miles at night in raging seas? It just wasn’t plausible in my view.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I haven’t read the book, but reviewers have led me to believe he would somehow get some of the boy’s money.


        • Fictionophile says:

          Even if he did get access to some of the boy’s money, the risk of going down in a plane crash and then the incredible swim afterwards would be FAR too much of risk. I found Scott Burroughs to be a ‘good guy’. The only character other than the boy that I really rooted for.

          Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s